For owners and operators Jorden Tarnoski and Victor Hernandez Jr., opening the first brick-and-mortar location for Creatures Coffee & Tea Co. is the result of steady growth, unwavering community support and a moment in time that felt undeniably right to take the next step forward.
Creatures spent years operating as a mobile coffee truck, learning how to adapt quickly and show up consistently in unpredictable conditions. Familiar faces showed up at the coffee truck week after week, no matter the weather, forming lines and building routines around their favorite drinks. Rather than taking that support for granted, the owners see it with deep gratitude.
“Operating on wheels taught us everything,” Tarnoski shared. The experience reinforced the importance of flexibility, resilience and staying deeply connected to the people they served. In many ways, the transition to a permanent space feels like a thank you, a way to give something lasting back to the community that believed in Creatures early on.
As demand continued to grow, it became clear the truck could no longer fully support what Creatures had become. The expansion wasn’t about growth for growth’s sake, but about honoring that loyalty and creating a space that could better serve customers in a more meaningful way. “That level of support gave us the confidence to take the leap,” Tarnoski said.
The new brick-and-mortar spot allows Creatures to slow things down intentionally. Guests are encouraged to sit with a drink, have a conversation and make Creatures part of their daily rhythm instead of just a quick stop. The permanent space offers room to linger and connect, shifting the experience from grab-and-go to something more personal and inviting.
The move also opened new opportunities behind the counter. Creatures has added long-anticipated matcha offerings, streamlined its menu and officially welcomed a few beloved customer-created drinks that had already earned loyal followings during the truck days.
Known for its “strange brews, great vibes” mantra, Creatures continues to lean into the horror-inspired aesthetic that has set it apart through deliciously crafted beverages with spooky twists. Inventive flavor combinations and playful nods to the macabre remain central to the menu, reflecting the same creativity and unconventional spirit customers have come to expect.
Maintaining that identity was essential throughout the transition. “Carrying the spirit of the truck into this new chapter was non-negotiable for us,” Tarnoski said. The creativity and customer connection that shaped Creatures from the beginning are built into the shop, from the menu and music to the way guests are greeted. The goal was never to feel polished at the expense of personality.
At its core, the new location represents a place where everything Creatures has been building can finally live and grow. The permanent space offers a sense of belonging where people can feel included, inspired and fully themselves. Grounded by community and guided by intention, Creatures Coffee & Tea Co. enters this next chapter with the same heart, the same flavors—and more room to share them.
Contact: creaturescoffeeandteaco.com | 5734 McArdle Road
View this post on Instagram
